'Pee-wee as Himself' and the Slippery Magic of Comic Identity
By Julia Krys
Unlike many pop culture phenomenons who receive a documentary post-mortem, Pee-wee as Himself, HBO’s new two-part documentary, offers a rare gift. Paul Reubens, the man behind the iconic man-child Pee-wee Herman, told his story in his own words. The documentary starts with a few title cards that lay out simple truths. There are over 40 hours of Reubens’ unreleased interview footage for this project. He was privately fighting cancer for years, and died suddenly before the project was complete.
Image Courtesy of NPR
From the outset, Reubens appears strikingly different from the wide-eyed, bow-tied character he’s known for. He curses. He meanders. He resists sentimentality. But every so often, he delivers a perfectly timed line that reminds us: this is someone who understands, intuitively and precisely, how to perform for a camera…even when the character is himself.
But what does it mean to perform yourself in a documentary about your life? Reubens’ struggle with control becomes a central tension. At times, he derails the conversation, turning directly to director Matt Wolf to complain about losing editorial power over the project. Then he breaks the fourth wall with a wink, signaling to the viewer that this conflict, too, might be part of the show. Or is it?
As someone unfamiliar with Reubens’s personal life before this film, I was surprised to learn how deeply Pee-Wee consumed him. As a closeted gay man, Reubens was more at ease approaching the world through Pee-wee’s eccentric filter than as himself. He blurred the line between character and creator so thoroughly that the public often couldn't tell where one ended and the other began.
This brand of hyper-conceptual comedy, where persona and performance fuse into one, reminds me of another comic mind who’s mastered the art of ambiguity: Nathan Fielder. In The Rehearsal, Fielder similarly toys with the boundary between fiction and reality, inviting the audience to question whether the awkward man onscreen is “Nathan,” or just a Nathan. Like Reubens, he layers persona atop persona until we no longer know what to believe. And that, perhaps, is the point.
Many comedians describe a great joke as a magic trick: misdirection and surprise, sleight of hand with language. Fielder even makes this comparison explicitly in The Rehearsal’s finale, showing old footage of himself as a teenage magician. But there’s a deeper kind of magic at play when a comic blurs the line between the authentic and the artificial—not just in punchlines, but in personality.
Image Courtesy of People
As a stand-up myself, I know how often the stories we tell are half-true, time-shifted, or completely fabricated. “Today I was…” usually means “Two years ago, this happened.” That “machete” was probably a butter knife. The mom who hates you? A loving woman who packed your lunch last week. But good comics know how to make an audience believe it just happened. That it’s all real. It’s a trick, yes. But an intentional one.
The work of Paul and Nathan operates on a much larger scale than a stand-up routine in the sense that they constantly live under the pretense that no one quite knows if their entire personality is a show. For Paul, the show became the opportunity for him to actually clear the air on who he really is, especially the controversies he was plagued with.
For Reubens, the stakes of that trick were higher. Pee-wee wasn’t just a character; he was a protective layer. And when that illusion shattered—after Reubens was arrested in a public indecency case that would later prove overblown and politically motivated—the fallout was devastating. The documentary offers Reubens a chance to reclaim the narrative. He doesn’t dwell on the most salacious details, nor does he spend time asking for pity. Instead, he sends one simple message: I am not a villain. I was just caught in a political trap.
Image Courtesy of @garybaseman
In comedy, the fusion of self and stage persona is common, but few live it as completely as Reubens did. Pee-wee as Himself is more than a retrospective; it’s a final performance. A magician revealing, just briefly, the trick behind the act, without ever letting us see exactly how it works.
More than anything, these two examples of comedians working within a documentary framework point to the emergence of a new genre: docu-comedy. We’ve long embraced the mockumentary (from The Office to Parks and Recreation) where scripted comedy borrows the aesthetics of nonfiction for laughs. But what happens when you remove the script entirely and throw both performers and real people into the same unpredictable sandbox? Pee-wee as Himself and The Rehearsal approach this question from radically different angles, yet both push the boundaries of what’s possible when comedy and documentary collide. If we’re lucky, these pieces will mark the beginning of a new era—one where unscripted comedy embraces ambiguity, contradiction, and just a little bit of magic.
