I’m Dreaming of a Title IX Christmas: 'Ebenezer' and Other Upcoming Releases Starring Disgraced Actors

By Reese Villella

As we approach the holiday season and the end of 2026, Hollywood seems to be working through its naughty list and giving leading roles to the men on it.

Citizen Vigilante, starring Armie Hammer (yes, that one), came out this past summer. I wrote about it in a previous article, looking at the film’s far-right, anti-immigrant messaging and how that coupled up nicely with an alleged rapist’s attempt at a comeback. You may have thought that Citizen Vigilante was a one-off, but that’s far from the case. The recent and upcoming release slate is filling up with familiar faces whose sexual misconduct allegations, abuse accusations, or criminal convictions have apparently ceased to be an obstacle to getting cast.

That leaves me with a rather profound question: What the hell is going on? More specifically, what is going on with the people making these movies? Someone has to finance these films, direct them, distribute them, and agree to spend several weeks acting opposite their leading men. And looking at these casts, it seems quite a few people are happy to participate.

Via IMDb.

Let’s start with Confession: the film, written by Ben Shapiro and directed by Václav Marhoul, follows a former professor imprisoned in Stalin-era Moscow. Its cast includes Rob Lowe, James Franco, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Nick Nolte, Brad Dourif, and Dean Norris. Now, of course, I don’t exactly have the highest expectations for people choosing to involve themselves in a film written by Ben Shapiro, the guy who thought the song “WAP” was an indication of a medical affliction because he was unfamiliar with the circumstances of female arousal. That being said, Confession nabbed some big-name alleged pieces of shit in this cast.

Franco was also the subject of a previous piece of mine, in which I discussed the TikTok trend romanticizing his alleged misconduct. For anyone who needs a refresher: former students at Franco’s Studio 4 acting school alleged that he and his associates used the school to sexually exploit young women under the guise of professional training, pressuring students into nudity and giving preferential treatment to those who participated. Franco and his co-defendants agreed to a settlement of more than $2.2 million in 2021 without admitting wrongdoing.

Lowe also has allegations in his history. His former nanny, Jessica Gibson, accused him of inappropriate touching in a countersuit after Lowe sued her, alleging that she had demanded money to remain silent. The court dismissed both parties’ lawsuits in 2009. And who could forget the time his sex tape leaked, exposing him for sleeping with a 16-year-old when he was 24? Lowe and Franco arrive at Confession from different places. Lowe’s professional rehabilitation happened long ago. His subsequent career has included years of steady television work. This is less a comeback for Lowe, as he achieved mainstream re-acceptance quite a while ago. 

Franco’s return has been considerably less seamless. Following a lengthy acting hiatus, much of his work has come through independent or international productions. This year, he also starred in Love, Lies & Frank, a vertical microseries for Shortical. Things got really grim for him, evidently. The platform presented his involvement as a milestone for the format, emphasizing the arrival of an Oscar-nominated actor.  

Now, I wouldn’t personally describe verticals as a thriving artistic frontier, but that doesn’t mean he accepted the project out of desperation. It merely illustrates how different things are now. In 2016, being James Franco meant you were hot shit, gearing up to release a film that would win you your second Golden Globe. In 2026, being James Franco means most of your acting is wedged between CatDoku ads.

Via Consequence.

The Daily Wire describes the film as an exploration of “what it means to be a free and decent human being.” A rather loaded selling point, considering the casting. Neither Shapiro nor the Daily Wire has directly reckoned with Franco’s or Lowe’s history.

Beyond the unsavory co-stars, I was surprised to see Jennifer Jason Leigh and Dean Norris in a Daily Wire movie. Leigh has a history of left-wing activism, and Norris is a Democrat who has previously attended multiple Democratic National Conventions. Apart from Leigh’s Zionism, it’s hard to imagine what these two might have in common with Shapiro ideologically. Of course, accepting a role doesn’t mean endorsing every position the writer holds. But the Daily Wire treats filmmaking as a way to advance its political agenda; accepting a role in a Daily Wire film is inherently political, regardless of personal beliefs. 

What’s striking is how much Hollywood credibility this supposedly anti-Hollywood enterprise depends on. Promoting Confession, Shapiro describes the Daily Wire’s filmmaking as part of a mission to compete with Hollywood and defend Western civilization. He then enthusiastically lists his cast’s Oscar, Emmy, and Golden Globe credentials. I suppose Hollywood’s judgment is worth something, so long as it can be printed on your promotional materials.

Confession isn’t the only Daily Wire project interested in platforming men with histories like these. Run Hide Fight: Infidels, the Daily Wire’s most recent installment in Islamophobic propaganda, stars Jonathan Majors, who you may recall was convicted of misdemeanor assault in a case involving his former girlfriend, Grace Jabbari. In April 2024, he received a conditional discharge and was sentenced to complete a 52-week domestic violence intervention program.

Via IMDb.

Like Franco or Lowe, giving Majors a second chance in Hollywood seems to incentivize the Daily Wire. An actor whose career has been damaged by controversy fits neatly into a brand built around opposition to “wokeness” and “cancel culture.” By casting Majors, the Daily Wire proves it refuses to submit to the standards of woke liberal Hollywood. The allegations against him are, in a way, helpful. Look at us! We’re so brave, we don’t even care he hits women. In fact, we LOVE that about him! Suck it, libs!!!! #Owned #Trump2028 #DisavowHasanPiker

The Daily Wire’s announcement of Majors’ return to the screen prominently features Harvey Levin’s claim that Hollywood “screwed” him and that “he won that case.” The article also acknowledges his assault and harassment convictions. But the sympathetic account of professional exile emphasizes something else for readers: he is a star who was unfairly discarded, and here is a company willing to take him back.

The film’s promotion uses a similar approach to criticism of its politics. One Daily Wire headline reads, “Hollywood Hates ‘Infidels.’ That’s Exactly Why You Should Watch It.” On social media, the company’s reels go further, celebrating the designation of the most Islamophobic movie of the year and telling critics to “sybau” (I wish I were kidding). It’s fascinating that even the Daily Wire implements a Gen Z marketing strategy. I didn’t know the Gen Z market was big enough to warrant using “sybau” in the Daily Wire’s marketing campaign; I thought all their viewers were middle-aged, divorced men.  

Via the official Run Hide Fight Instagram.

Shapiro does dispute the Islamophobia accusations, arguing that depicting ISIS does not implicate all Muslims. Yet he closes this defense by anticipating how much angrier the left will be after seeing the film. This is their marketing strategy--a negative review becomes an endorsement depending on the critic’s political affiliation. 

Outside the slimy world of Daily Wire media, you’d think we’d find refuge, but no, because then we have Day Drinker and Ebenezer. Johnny Depp stars in the former alongside Penélope Cruz and Madelyn Cline, and in the latter, where he plays (you guessed it) Ebenezer Scrooge. These projects come from mainstream Hollywood itself, with respected filmmakers and familiar ensembles.

Depp has denied Amber Heard’s allegations of domestic abuse, and the legal history deserves more precision than the comeback headlines tend to offer. In 2020, a British judge dismissed his libel claim against The Sun, finding its description of him as a “wife beater” substantially true. In a separate 2022 U.S. case, a jury found that Heard defamed Depp, while also finding for Heard on one of her counterclaims. For a fuller examination of the allegations and the public treatment of Heard, I recommend Rayne Fisher-Quann’s essay “Who’s Afraid of Amber Heard?”

Via ABC News.

Ebenezer’s cast includes Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman, Daisy Ridley, Ian McKellen, Sam Claflin, and Ellie Bamber. It’s a Paramount release directed by Ti West, whose X, Pearl, and MaXXXine trilogy I quite liked, and has (ironically) been widely accepted into the feminist horror conversation. This is part of why this announcement gave me pause. These are people whose work I watch, whose names interest me, and whose involvement might ordinarily make me more excited to see a film.

I mean, Rupert Grint was such a big part of my childhood. What’s next? Is he gonna return to the Harry Potter franchise and help transphobe J.K. Rowling fill her pockets? Surely he wouldn’t do that after declaring in 2020, “Trans women are women. Trans men are men,” right? Right???

I can’t fault below-the-line crew or extras in the same way. Their involvement in a film of this scale can advance their careers and may be financially essential, and they do not influence who gets cast. Established stars and filmmakers have far more leverage to turn down a project than a best boy grip who just got their first gig on a major Hollywood production. 

Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past via Bloody Disgusting.

Of course, accepting a role doesn’t tell us what an actor thinks about their co-star’s history. But their participation lends the project some credibility. And as their name appears on the poster alongside the alleged abuser’s, their participation gives an audience member a reason to buy a ticket. And that can become a reason to support said abuser or even absolve them. If this person I like is working with them, they can’t be all that bad.

Some of these collaborators have also publicly advocated for survivors. Ellie Bamber became an ambassador for the domestic-abuse charity Refuge in 2024. She has been outspoken about rape culture for years and has even recently shared several Instagram posts about the Cornell Seven. On the other hand, Penélope Cruz has supported #MeToo, but has supported Depp personally for years. In fact, she submitted a declaration on his behalf in 2020, drawing on her friendship and professional experience with him. Her involvement in Day Drinker follows this established relationship.

Cruz is interesting because it raises the question of how public convictions can conflict with personal and professional obligations. Cruz may sincerely oppose abuse, but she may also believe a particular allegation is untrue. The problem is that a positive experience with a colleague cannot establish what happened in someone else’s relationship. 

Cruz and Depp in 2025 via People.

The responsibility extends well beyond the women in these casts. Directors, producers, studio executives, and male co-stars all help make the return possible. But what does that collective participation communicate? A respected ensemble can make a controversial casting decision feel like a non-issue. Look at everyone who signed on. Surely, someone has worked this out.

The “comeback” framing is hardly something I’m imposing on the film. According to The New York Times, Paramount’s teaser announces, “The master of misfits returns,” followed by Depp’s Scrooge declaring, “It’s good to be back.” The studio is explicitly encouraging audiences to recognize this film as pivotal: Depp’s big return to the screen! 

People’s coverage supplies the emotional details. In a July 28 article, unnamed sources describe Depp as “happy,” “entering a new chapter,” and revitalized by his Comic-Con appearance. His comeback is described as a “once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.” The “comeback” framing works well for Depp because of what it disregards. He was successful, something happened, he lost what he had, and now he’s finding his way back. It gives us a protagonist to follow and an outcome to anticipate. Will he reclaim his career? Will audiences welcome him? Does he still have that star quality? Notice whose experience is left out of that narrative. 

According to The Times, Paramount is assessing whether Depp’s familiarity and appeal can translate into ticket sales. As film professor Miranda Banks puts it in the article, “Hollywood needs this comeback,” citing a shortage of stars who can attract audiences worldwide. The industry has a financial interest in making established stars usable again. A familiar face comes with an audience, after all, even if it’s attached to a person who is allegations-ridden. The question becomes whether that appeal remains strong enough to outweigh the controversy.

Time doesn’t erase controversy, but it can push it aside and make it feel less urgent when a big-budget Paramount teaser is right in front of your face. How theatrical! How sparkly! How big! The allegations become background information as the trailer becomes the news. His transformation! His performance! His long-awaited return! Eventually, bringing up the past can make you seem like the person refusing to move on. But why would we move on? Has something meaningful changed?

Depp in the Ebenezer trailer.

There’s also something almost too convenient about staging this return through A Christmas Carol, a story in which a difficult man confronts his past and earns a place back in the community. That doesn’t establish why Depp was cast, but it has some convenient parallels to his comeback campaign: reflection, transformation, forgiveness, another chance.

The Daily Wire’s approach invites audiences to celebrate defying the people who object while mainstream Hollywood offers a more comfortable invitation: a beloved story, a director you like, a cast you trust. Both give audiences reasons to celebrate these men’s return without seriously confronting the allegations that interrupted their careers in the first place.

Will you find yourself in the theater for Ebenezer this Christmas? If so, will it be because you’re morbidly curious, or because you’re kind of excited to see Johnny back on the big screen? Is the narrative working on you? Is the years-long smear campaign burned into your brain to the point where you’ve forgotten the time Depp said he wanted to burn and defile Amber’s corpse? All you may remember is that her dog stepped on a bee, or Depp being questioned about pouring himself a mega pint of beer. But beyond the memes, notice how you find it easier to believe that a woman is some kind of conspiratorial mastermind than it is to believe that a grown man (a celebrity, a father, a nice guy) is capable of violence.

Previous
Previous

Dating App Fatigue: Why Do I Have to Swipe to Feel Seen?

Next
Next

Sally Rooney, Palestine, and the Question of Literary Censorship